• Classic Peanut Butter Classic Peanut Butter

    Classic Peanut Butter

    From $8.00 USD
    From $8.00 USD
  • Dark Chocolate Almond Butter Dark Chocolate Almond Butter

    Dark Chocolate Almond Butter

    From $10.00 USD
    From $10.00 USD
  • Habanero Honey Peanut Butter Habanero Honey Peanut Butter

    Habanero Honey Peanut Butter

    From $7.00 USD
    From $7.00 USD
  • Pistachio Butter Pistachio Butter

    Pistachio Butter

    From $10.00 USD
    From $10.00 USD

Freshly ground in small batches

Our spoon-worthy nut butters are crafted with care to be irresistibly fresh and flavorful, always low in sugar, and packed with protein. Made from simple, wholesome ingredients, they’re perfect for spreading, dipping, cooking, baking, smoothie-ing, or just diving in spoon-first.

Shop Collections

Plenty of good stuff, none of the bad stuff

  • High Protein

  • Gluten-Free

  • No GMO's

  • No Trans Fats

  • Kosher

Recipes

Testimonials

What Clients Are Saying!

  • All of the Nut Butters are amazing, coming from a nut butter addict!

    Michelle H.

  • Sooo yummy! And the best part is it’s healthy!!! My ultimate favorite is the Cinnamon Almond Butter. I use it in my smoothies, on my waffles, or just by the spoonful!

    Sarah C.

  • Holy Smokes! The Habanero Honey Peanut Butter was awesome!

    Mark D.

ABOUT US

Small Family Business Operated

Brothers Caleb and Jesse Mangum run Nutty Novelties with a small but mighty team who craft our nut butters in Telford, PA and serve them up at retailers and farmers’ markets across the region. Every jar you buy helps us keep doing what we love—creating bold new flavors, supporting local events, and sharing the goodness one spoon-worthy bite at a time.